Pickle Stocking Stuffers Under $25: Gifts Every Pickle Lover Wants

The stocking is where the best little gifts hide. And for the pickle lover in your family (there is always one), nothing beats pulling a real jar out of the toe on Christmas morning. Here is our full list of pickle stocking stuffers under $25, plus the bigger gift to put under the tree.

Why a jar of pickles is the best stocking stuffer

• It gets eaten, not re-gifted. A jar is a treat they open the same week, not another trinket for the junk drawer.
• It is better than the grocery store. Every [PICKLES] jar is handcrafted in small batches in our Atlanta kitchen with Georgia-grown cucumbers. The crunch is the giveaway.
• It suits almost everyone. Gluten-free and vegan, no dyes, and 79% less sodium.
• It has a story. Our pickles have won a Good Food Award and Flavor of Georgia.
• It keeps. Unopened jars are shelf-stable, so you can order early and tuck them away until Christmas Eve.

Single jars under $25 (by personality)

Every jar below is $16.95. Match the flavor to the person and it looks like you thought about it for weeks.

For the classic dill fan: The Dill Chips

The Dill Chips are crisp, salty and zesty with a bright dill taste. A safe bet for anyone who says "just a normal pickle, please."

For the one who always wins: The Banana Pickle

The Banana Pickle is named for banana peppers, and it is not spicy. It tastes like a well-balanced garlic dill, and it won Flavor of Georgia Best Pickle 2024. You get to say "it is award-winning" when they open it.

For the hot-sauce relative: The Ghost Pickle

The Ghost Pickle is a 4 out of 5 on our heat scale and the only jar we make that stings. Want something hot but friendlier? Anything named "Spicy" is a 3 out of 5, made with chili flakes and habanero, like The Spicy Okra. See the full heat scale.

For the sweet tooth: The Grape Pickle

The Grape Pickle is our November-to-December holiday pickle: sweet and tangy with one clove and cinnamon pickling spice. It tastes like the season. Prefer a classic sweet chip? The Bread and Butter has brown and white sugar and cinnamon pickling spice, and no clove.

For the pucker lover: The Power Sour

The Power Sour is the most sour jar on our sour scale. If they drink the brine straight, this is theirs. More in our extra sour pickles guide.

For the person who is impossible to shop for: The Random Flavor

The Random Flavor is one surprise jar picked from our 40+ flavors. You do not even have to choose.

For the brine sipper: The Pickle Juice

The Pickle Juice is our signature brine with herbs, garlic and spices, bottled for sipping and picklebacks. Ideas in our pickle juice guide.

The Banana PickleFlavor of Georgia Best Pickle 2024. Not spicy, all garlic dill.Shop · $16.95The Grape PickleOur holiday pickle: clove and cinnamon, sweet and tangy.Shop · $16.95The Ghost Pickle4 out of 5 heat. The stocking stuffer for the dare-taker.Shop · $16.95The Random FlavorOne surprise jar from 40+ flavors.Shop · $16.95

Pickle stocking stuffers that are not jars

The Christmas Pickle Ornament ($16)

The legendary Christmas pickle: hide the ornament in the tree, and whoever finds it first on Christmas morning gets good luck (and, in many families, an extra gift). The full story is in the Christmas pickle tradition. Pair it with a jar for the perfect stocking combo.

Pickle Pins & Earrings ($12)

A Pickle Chip Pin, a Pickle Jar Pin or Pickle Earrings. Tiny, enamel and very green, and small enough for any stocking.

The Pickle Bandana ($12)

Two pickle prints. Wear it as a neckerchief or headband, or tie it on the dog. It also makes a great wrap for a gifted jar.

Pickle Glasses ($12) and the Pickle Cap Hat ($25)

Pickle Party sunglasses come in four styles, and the Pickle Cap Hat has our embroidered pickle logo. Both are for the friend who wears their pickle love loudly.

A gift card (from $15) and a greeting card ($4)

Not sure which flavor? A [PICKLES] gift card lets them choose from 40+ flavors. Add a pickle greeting card with your own note to any order.

Ready to go bigger? The under-the-tree upgrade

Once the stocking is full, the main gift can be a box. The 2-Jar Gift Box ($44) and the 3-Jar Pickle Party Pack ($65) arrive gift-ready, and themed boxes like The Blazing Box, The Sweet Box and The Dill Box match the person. Want to choose every jar yourself? Build Your Pickle Box.

For the gift that lasts well past New Year, the [PICKLES] CLUB sends six curated jars every month, with new flavors and early drops, and 15% off on a 12-month membership. See what comes in the box in our Pickle of the Month Club guide.

2-Jar Gift BoxTwo bestselling jars, gift-boxed.Shop · $44.003-Jar Pickle Party PackOne classic, one with a kick, one wildcard.Shop · $65.00[PICKLES] CLUBSix new jars every month. The gift that keeps arriving.Shop · $99.00

More holiday ideas: our Christmas gift guide for pickle lovers, holiday hostess gifts and corporate holiday gifts.

Pickle stocking stuffer FAQ

What is a good stocking stuffer for a pickle lover?

A single 17 oz jar of their favorite flavor ($16.95), the Christmas Pickle Ornament ($16), or pickle pins, earrings or a bandana ($12). Combine two or three for a full pickle stocking.

When should I order for Christmas?

Order early. Every jar is handcrafted, and unopened jars are shelf-stable, so you can order in November or early December and store them until Christmas Eve.

Is shipping free?

US shipping is free on any 2+ jars, and if you spend $150 you get a free jar.

Are the jars spicy?

Most are not. The Dill Chips, The Banana Pickle, The Grape Pickle, The Bread and Butter and The Power Sour have no heat. Anything named "Spicy" is a 3 out of 5, and The Ghost Pickle is a 4 out of 5.